Sign up for our newsletters   

Baltimore City Paper home.

film Home > Movie Reviews


They Wuz Robbed! 1994

Heavenly Creatures

Heavenly Creatures

Director:Peter Jackson
Cast:Melanie Lynskey, Kate Winslet
Genre:Film, Drama

By Ian Grey | Posted

Won: Forrest Gump

Robbed: Heavenly Creatures

The Oscar ritual exists primarily for two reasons: To honor fiscal gain, and to congratulate the industry for what it likes to believe itself to be--liberal, artistically progressive, provocative (but not too provocative). In 1994, one movie merged these traditions and was swept to Best Picture glory: the box-office heavyweight Forrest Gump, which encouraged us to embrace the unquestioning stupidity of its title character as the most American of goals. The New Zealand-made Heavenly Creatures, on the other hand, had nothing going for it but brilliance. Its near-total neglect by the Academy powerfully demonstrates how little room there is for artistry in the ascendant monoculture of post-corporate movies.

Gump was a perfect Clinton-era diversion. Its multigenerational tale of a mysteriously blessed imbecile (Tom Hanks) oozed taffy-brained, feel-good liberalism that obfuscated its true, staunchly reactionary politics (a woman in Gump contracts AIDS for being sexually independent; black characters worship Hanks' idiot savant). Six Academy Awards were duly parceled out.

Although nominated for Best Original Screenplay (the winner was the clever pop-culture truffle Pulp Fiction), Heavenly Creatures was anti-Oscar in every conceivable way. Its fact-based story of two teenaged girls (perfectly portrayed by Melanie Lynskey and Kate Winslet) who eventually kill one of their mothers was used by director/co-screenwriter Peter Jackson as a means to explore the essential mysteries and possibly innate destructiveness of youth. The two girls grow close, and as their intimacy incrementally creates a hermetic, fantasy-fueled universe of two, adult loathing of their suspected lesbianism threatens to separate them from one another--which, with terrible irony, convinces them that nothing short of matricide will succeed in reuniting them. Heavenly Creatures is film as delightful/disturbing literature. Reality and the fevers of imagination fluidly glide into one another to unforgettable effect. It's what the movies are all about. Except on Oscar night.

Comments powered by Disqus
CP on Facebook
CP on Twitter